Journal of Taibah University Medical Sciences

From formal compliance to measured performance: a structured review and quantitative synthesis of the evidence underpinning medical examination of conscription-age men

Journal of Taibah University Medical Sciences

Date: 14-10-2026

Volume: 21 · Issue: 5 · Pages: 1208–1229

Show more

Structured Review

From formal compliance to measured performance: a structured review and quantitative synthesis of the evidence underpinning medical examination of conscription-age men

Show more

Abstract

Background

Medical examination of conscription-age men is performed largely by civilian primary care, yet its quality is judged almost exclusively by downstream military outcomes.

Objective

To quantify the evidence on disease burden in this population, on the diagnostic performance of the components of the examination, and on interventions that change professional performance, and to derive a testable indicator framework for quality management.

Methods

Structured review of PubMed/MEDLINE and Cochrane sources to October 2026 (meta-analyses, randomised controlled trials [RCTs], national cohorts and regulatory documents of the Republic of Uzbekistan). Estimates were extracted as reported; where counts or confidence intervals permitted, proportions with Wilson 95% CI, odds/risk ratios with Woolf 95% CI and exact two-sided p values were computed (χ² or Fisher's exact test; Altman–Bland method).

Results

Prevalence in conscription-age men spanned more than two orders of magnitude, from 23.5% for myopia to 0.12% for HIV, with potentially lethal cardiac disorders in 0.34% (95% CI 0.29–0.40)†. Obesity among 1.5 million Austrian conscripts rose from 1.6% to 8.2% between 1983 and 2017 (+6.6 percentage points; p<0.001†). Within the examination, diagnostic performance differed sharply: electrocardiography detected 94% of lethal cardiac disorders against 20% for history and 9% for physical examination. Concordance between records and self-report was no better than moderate (κ 0.23–0.51), so measured prevalence depended on the method of ascertainment. Audit and feedback, the only quality intervention with large randomised evidence (292 RCTs), produced a mean absolute improvement in desired practice of 6.2% (95% CI 4.1–8.2; OR 1.47, 1.31–1.64), rising when baseline performance was low. Regional fitness for service rose by 14.4 percentage points over 12 years (OR 2.02; 1.94–2.11; p<0.001†) where health-improvement work was organised systematically.

Conclusions

The examination is currently managed as a legal procedure and not as a measurable clinical process. A 15-indicator structure–process–outcome framework, with instrumentally verified rather than self-reported inputs and audit and feedback as the delivery mechanism, is proposed for prospective testing.

Authors and affiliations

Shoira Q. Abdusattarova
Tashkent, Republic of Uzbekistan
Corresponding author
nagaeva.gulnora@mail.ru

Saidakhon Sh. Mirrakhimova
Tashkent, Republic of Uzbekistan

Keywords

conscript; medical examination; military medical expertise; primary health care; quality indicator; quality of health care

Full article

The PDF viewer is unavailable. Download the full article PDF.

How to cite

Abdusattarova S. Q., Mirrakhimova S. Sh. (2026). From formal compliance to measured performance: a structured review and quantitative synthesis of the evidence underpinning medical examination of conscription-age men. Journal of Taibah University Medical Sciences, 21(5), 1208–1229. DOI: 10.1016/j.jtumed.2026.10.14.